Bit of a trick question this, and also an either/or – in that there are only two candidates and I would guess that most people would go for the wrong one (the Isle of Man).
Anglesey is 276 square miles in area, compared to the Isle of Man's 221 square miles. The third largest island in the Irish Sea is Holy Island (off Anglesey) – 15 square miles.
© Macclesfield Quiz League 2017